OATdb Archive

2014 - 2015

Political Science MA

Goal
Written Comprehensive Exams
Students will gain knowledge and skills that are associated with advanced degrees in political science.

Objective
Written Comprehensive Exams
Upon completion of the MA in Political Science program, students will be able to:

1. Explain the key features of methodology.
2. Evaluate political theories and discuss the significant research in one of the program's subject areas: American government, public administration, comparative politics, or international relations.


Indicator
Successful Completion Of Written Comprehensive Exams
We utilize written comprehensive exams as a tool for measuring graduate students' knowledge and skills. Prior to graduation, students complete two written comprehensive exams in areas relevant to their coursework. Exam questions are written by faculty with expertise in the students' areas of study and the questions are based on the comprehensive exam reading lists and the content of the overview courses (see department level goal of revise written comprehensive exam process for more information on the reading lists and overview courses). Students' exams are graded by at least two faculty members (more when possible) who have expertise in the areas of study pursued by students. Exams are assigned one of the following scores: high pass, pass, and no pass. If the two faculty members issue conflicting scores (e.g., pass and no pass), a third faculty member will be asked to score the exams and issue a final ruling.

Criterion
Written Comprehensive Exams
We expect that at least 80% of our students will pass their exams on the first attempt and that 100% of the students who have to take the exam a second time will pass.

Finding
Comprehensive Exam Results
The new comprehensive exam format consist of two sections. Five students took exams in spring and summer 2015. On the first round of exams two out of five students received high passes on the first and second sections, two out of five students received passes on the first section and fails on the second section, and one student received fails on both sections. All three students who took sections of the exam a second time passed. 

On section one of the exam, four out of five students passed the exam with two receiving high passes. Thus, we were pleased with students performance on the first section of the exams. Three out of five students failed the second section of the exam, but passed the second section on their second attempt.  Although the three students passed on the second section on their second attempt, the rate of passes on the second section of the exam needs to improve.


Action
Written Comprehensive Exams
The MA in Political Science will move completely online in fall 2016. The move will require faculty to re-evaluate the program curriculum and thus the content and delivery mode of the comprehensive exams. The MA director and faculty will use this coming year to make the necessary changes in the curriculum and comprehensive exams.

Goal
Improve Students' Critical Thinking Skills
Students will learn to think critically and reflectively.


Objective
Changing The Written Comprehensive Exam Process
MA faculty wish to design a comprehensive exam process that will require students to rely more on informed reflection and less on memorization when preparing for the exams. The written comprehensive exam questions will be rewritten to require students to demonstrate reflective and critical thought.

Indicator
Exam Process Revisions
The MA director, in consultation with faculty from the discipline's subfields, will develop a database of exam questions  designed to require students to demonstrate critical thought.

Criterion
Exam Process Revisions
The new comprehensive exam questions will be developed in the fall of 2014 and implemented in the spring of 2015. We believe the new questions will decrease the amount of memorization based exam answers and increase the amount of critical thinking based exam answers.

Finding
Number Of High Passes Awarded
We were pleased to see two students receive high passes on their first attempts on the first section of the exam.


Action
Critical Thinking Skills
The MA in Political Science will move completely online in fall 2016. The move will require faculty to re-evaluate the program curriculum and thus the content and delivery mode of the comprehensive exams. The MA director and faculty will use this coming year to make the necessary changes in the curriculum and comprehensive exams.

Goal
Gradudate Student Writing Skills
Graduate students will develop strong writing skills


Objective
Improving Graduate Student Writing Skills
The writing skills of students will improve during their first year in the program.


Indicator
Identifying Students With Weak Writing Skills
At the beginning of each semester the MA director will send graduate faculty the names of all students new to the program. Faculty will alert the director to any new student whose first written assignment indicates weak writing skills. Two faculty members will assess the sample and confirmthe weaknesses.

Criterion
Improved Writing Skills
We believe the writing skills of students who are referred to the Writing Center will improve. Two or more faculty who cited the weak student evaluate a second writing after the student has received training at the SHSU Writing Center.  All referred students must show demonstrated improvement to the satisfaction of the assessing faculty.

Finding
Results Of Efforts To Improve Writing Skills
Overall, MA faculty noticed a difference in the quality of some students' application writing samples (all prospective students must submit a writing sample) and written work submitted in classes. Class written assignments were weaker than application writing samples.  Faculty hypothesized the submitted writing samples for the application process represented highly polished texts possibly achieved with coaching.  The first paper intervention process was designed to identify such instances and rapidly bring students to consistent improved writing performance.  During the AY 2014/2015 one student was identified as in need of improvement. The student worked with Writing Center. Subsequently, two faculty members confirmed writing improved to the acceptable graduate peformance level.  The student also raised their overall GPA significantly between the alert to poor writing and the sessions with the Writing Center.

Action
Writing Skills
The MA in Political Science will move completely online in fall 2016. The pool of prospective students for the online degree include full time professionals in the fields of education, government, and non-profits. We expect that this pool of prospective students will possess strong writing skills. Thus, the need to monitor incoming students' writing may fade as new students enter the program. If this is not the case, we will design a strategy appropriate for improving the writing skills of students who are taking courses online rather than face-to-face.


Update to previous cycle's plan for continuous improvement Changes to the written comprehensive exams were implemented and efforts to address graduate students' writing skills were made.

Plan for continuous improvement This coming year the department will begin taking the steps necessary to move the MA online. The move towards an online program will likely affect the type of students we recruit (i.e., traditional students versus full time professionals), the reasons the students are purposing the degree (e.g., wanting to use a MA as a means of getting into doctoral programs versus using a MA as a means of furthering an existing professional career), etc. The director and MA Committee will use this coming year to rethink key aspects of the program, such as: student learing objectives and program curriculum, comprehensive exam processes that are conducive to an online program, measurement tools that can be used to measure students' skill and knowledge before entering the program and upon graduating from the program, etc.